“Shared Decision-Making” and You

An excellent new study from  Canada’s Manitoba province explores the factors in successful interaction between patients and their physicians.  I’m interested in what you, our readers, think makes for patient-physician communication success–or failure.


photo of decorative church with three spires

Ukrainian Catholic Church, Cook's Corner, Manitoba


The study is featured in the Journal of Participatory Medicine, the great new resource we’ve mentioned previously.  Authored by Brenda L. Lovell, Raymond T. Lee, and Celeste M. Brotheridge, the study report assesses the relative importance of many factors.  Physicians in the study identified three major barriers to communication:

  • patients’ failures to follow through with treatment plans or lifestyle changes
  • insufficient time for patient visits, and
  • patients’ failures to understand the diagnosis.

The major barriers to the patient and physician’s  shared understanding, according to the physicians, are:

  • patient presents too many problems
  • patient’s history is rambling and disorganized, and
  • insufficient time.

The major barriers to shared decision-making by the patient and physician, according to the physicians, are:

  • patient does not appear to trust physician
  • patient is uninterested in self-care or health maintenance, and
  • patient does not want to participate in a partnership with the physician.

There are lots of limitations to this study, as the authors note.  (There also are lots of limitations to our own brief summary, above.)   But, it’s important for patients to have a sense of the pitfalls that physicians are on the lookout for.  If you immediately bring one or more of these barriers to the doctor’s mind, he or she is likely to dismiss the possibility of successful communication–and to hurry on the next patient.

After all, what would you do if you had to see dozens of clients every day and the client in front of you gave the appearance of being uncooperative?

In essence, that’s what our book “Make the Health Care System Work for You!” is all about.   We suggest practical ways to become engaged and help create a fruitful partnership with your doctor.  We think the patient is one side of the communication equation and can’t rely on the doctor to do all the work.

The major limitation of the Manitoba study is that it only presents the doctor’s viewpoint.  We need the patient’s viewpoint.  We need to know what pleases or annoys patients who seek a shared understanding and shared decision-making.

Any ideas?

Photo credit:  gurdonarkAttribution.


2 Responses to “Shared Decision-Making” and You

  1. Glenn Weisfeld says:

    Another limitation for US citizens would seem to be that this was a Canadian study.

    I’m interested in learning more about the book that was mentioned. Who wrote it–the study authors? How can it be purchased?

  2. New Associates says:

    Absolutely!–Findings might be a little different in parts of the U.S.

    To order or see sections of the book, please click on “The Book” at the upper right or on top of the home page of this blog site. Comments encouraged!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: